Peter Schiff: Bitcoin Holders Are Losing Big While Precious Metals Hit New Records

Economist and longtime market commentator Peter Schiff has again urged Bitcoin investors to reconsider their positions.

He insists that precious metals are sending clearer signals amid today’s shifting economic landscape. In a series of posts on X, Schiff said that while Gold and Silver continue to surge, Bitcoin has struggled to deliver comparable returns.

His comments come amid rising volatility across currency, bond, and crypto markets. He argues that such conditions tend to favor traditional stores of value.

Key Points

• Gold reached $4,967 per ounce, setting a record high.
• Silver climbed to $99.24 per ounce, also reaching a record high.
• The U.S. Dollar Index fell to 98.37, a weekly decline of about 1%.
• Bitcoin traded near $89,234, down 0.6% for the day and roughly 30% below its prior peak.
• Since November 2021, Bitcoin has lost more than 50% of its value relative to Gold.

Precious Metals Rise as the Dollar Weakens

Schiff pointed to fresh record highs in precious metals as evidence of changing investor priorities. Gold recently climbed to $4,967 per ounce, while Silver reached $99.24, with both metals setting new all-time highs.

At the same time, the U.S. Dollar Index fell to 98.37, marking a weekly decline of roughly 1%. According to Schiff, this divergence underscores mounting pressure on the dollar, reflecting heightened financial strain. It also illustrates why investors are increasingly seeking protection in hard assets.

Against this backdrop, Bitcoin has failed to keep pace, raising questions about its performance during periods of monetary stress.

As of this writing, Bitcoin was trading near $89,234, down 0.60% on the day and roughly 30% below its previous peak. Schiff contended that the primary risk for long-term holders is not a sudden market collapse. Instead, it lies in the opportunity cost of capital immobilized in an underperforming asset.

In his view, investors who remained in Bitcoin have missed substantial gains available in precious metals—a gap he described as increasingly difficult to overlook.

Measuring Bitcoin Against Gold

To reinforce his argument, Schiff compared Bitcoin’s performance against Gold rather than fiat currencies. He claimed that since Bitcoin’s November 2021 high, its value has declined by more than 50% when measured in Gold terms.

This comparison, he said, reveals a deeper, longer-term erosion of purchasing power that is masked when Bitcoin is measured solely against the dollar.

Despite his criticism, Schiff acknowledged Bitcoin’s early success. He noted that it delivered extraordinary gains during its initial adoption phase when ownership was limited.

However, he argued that performance declined as institutional investors and Wall Street entered the market. Schiff added that this broader participation coincided with a decrease in relative returns.

Questioning Bitcoin Role During Monetary Stress

Moreover, Schiff questioned Bitcoin’s ability to fulfill its long-promoted role as “digital gold.” He argued that Bitcoin’s failure to mirror Gold’s recent rally undermines that narrative and casts doubt on its effectiveness as a hedge during monetary turmoil.

He warned that prolonged underperformance could ultimately precipitate a sharp market correction. Meanwhile, elevated precious metal prices may be indicative of deeper structural issues linked to rising debt levels.

Although market conditions remain fluid, Schiff’s latest remarks reinforce his long-standing preference for Gold and Silver. Once again, he frames precious metals, not Bitcoin, as safer havens during periods of economic and monetary uncertainty.